OnPay Payroll
4.8 (192)
Simple all-in-one payroll, HR, and benefits at one flat price.
Find the right payroll software, faster.
Stop paying for features you will never use. Compare the top payroll and HR tools by price, features, and real user reviews.
Trusted by leading payroll and HR platforms
GustoPaychexBambooHRQuickBooksPaycomPaylocityisolvedPaycor
Top-rated solutions
Based on thousands of verified user reviews and expert analysis.
Remote People
4.8 (102)
Global EOR and payroll to hire in 180+ countries (formerly Horizons).
Gusto HR Software
4.6 (1,032)
Full-service payroll, benefits, and HR for small and growing teams.
QuickBooks Payroll
4.4 (453)
Cloud payroll and tax filing that plugs straight into QuickBooks accounting.
PrimePay
4.3 (236)
Payroll and HCM for SMBs, with on-demand pay and self-service.
Paychex Flex
4.0 (372)
All-in-one HCM, payroll, and HR with 24/7 support for any size team.
How Compare Payroll works
Skip the guesswork. Get to the right tool in three simple steps.
1
Tell us your needs
Share your team size, budget, and the features that matter most to you.
2
See your matches
We narrow the market to a short list of tools that fit your business.
3
Compare and choose
Read real reviews, compare features side by side, and pick with confidence.
Need help deciding?
Talk to payroll experts for free.
Tell us your budget and what your team needs. We will send back the right tools and get back to you fast. No pressure, no spam.
Compare payroll software prices and save
Compare 45 payroll, HR, and time tracking tools in one place.
What payroll features are you mainly looking for?
Browse by category
Find the right tool for every part of your people operations.
Frequently asked questions
Quick answers to common questions to help you better understand our reviews, features, and service.
It depends on your team size, budget, and whether you need extras like benefits administration, time tracking, or global payroll. The right fit usually balances ease of use, transparent pricing, and the features you actually use every month. Browse our directory by category to narrow the market to a short list, then read reviews to pick with confidence.
If you have more than a couple of employees, dedicated software saves time and reduces costly tax errors. It automates filings, direct deposit, and compliance, which is hard to manage by hand as you grow.
Most leading tools integrate with popular accounting platforms like QuickBooks and Xero, plus time tracking and benefits providers. Check each tool's integrations on its details page before you decide.
Many tools use a base monthly fee plus a per employee charge. Entry plans often start around $40 per month plus a few dollars per person, while applicant tracking tools commonly start around $49 to $79 per month. Enterprise platforms usually require a custom quote.
Ratings combine verified user reviews with our own hands on analysis of features, pricing, and support. We summarize the common themes so you get an honest view of the strengths and the trade offs.
Yes. Browsing, comparing, and getting a recommendation are completely free for buyers. Vendors pay to reach buyers and to claim their listings.